Skip to content

Which Open-Source WhatsApp Alternatives Best Protect Your Privacy?

Your private messages, family photos, and work conversations pass through WhatsApp every day. End-to-end encryption protects their content…

Femme utilisant une application de messagerie sécurisée sur smartphone dans un café, alternative libre à WhatsApp pour protéger sa vie privée

Your private messages, family photos, and work conversations pass through WhatsApp every day. End-to-end encryption protects the content of your conversations, but the app collects metadata (contacts, how often you communicate, location) and shares it with Meta.

Since February 2024, Signal has let users create a username to start a conversation without revealing their phone number—a concrete step toward separating identity from messaging. For anyone looking to take back control of their data, several open-source messaging apps offer very different approaches.

The practical cost of switching, depending on how you use messaging

Switching messaging apps is about more than installing an app. The real challenge is convincing your contacts to switch and making sure you don’t lose your chat history or access to your messages. The effort involved varies considerably depending on whether you’re coordinating a family, an association, or a work team.

For a family, Signal is still the simplest option. Signing up requires a phone number, so your relatives don’t need to create a new account. Contacts are discovered automatically. However, transferring your chat history when you change phones requires a manual step.

An association managing several topic-based groups may find more flexibility with Element, which is based on the Matrix protocol. Each room can be hosted on a server chosen by the association. The trade-off is that you’ll need to understand device verification and encryption key recovery, or risk losing access to older messages when you switch devices.

For a professional team, Element also offers bridges to other protocols, making it easier to work alongside existing tools. Finding an open-source alternative to WhatsApp that fits your needs can help you avoid ending up with a technically perfect app that nobody uses.

Man working on a secure open-source messaging app from his home office, protecting his digital privacy

Signal, Element, Threema: what really sets them apart on privacy

These three messaging apps are often mentioned together, but they don’t protect your privacy in the same way.

Signal and default encryption

Signal encrypts all messages, voice calls, and video calls end to end without requiring any action from the user. Its source code is open and regularly audited. Signal collects the least metadata of any mainstream messaging app. Since 2024, phone numbers have no longer been visible by default to new contacts, thanks to usernames. You still need a phone number to sign up, so Signal isn’t completely anonymous.

Element and control over hosting

Element is based on Matrix, an open-source, federated protocol. In practice, this means you can host your own server or choose one you trust. Privacy then depends on the server’s configuration and how encryption keys are managed. Not all rooms are encrypted by default, so you need to check the settings whenever you create a group. This flexibility suits technically capable organizations, but is less ideal for users who want a ready-to-use solution.

Threema and signing up without a phone number

Threema is a paid app developed in Switzerland. It doesn’t require a phone number or email address to create an account. Each user receives a random ID. Its source code is open. Threema is the only mainstream option that removes any link to a phone number. The one-time purchase price can be a barrier: your contacts have to buy it too.

Backups and switching phones: the pitfall comparison guides overlook

Have you ever lost messages when switching phones? This can happen with any messaging app, but each handles it differently.

On WhatsApp, the level of backup protection depends on the settings you choose. With a standard backup, your cloud storage provider can read your messages.

  • On Signal, backups are stored locally and encrypted. You have to transfer the file to your new phone yourself. This requires a small but deliberate technical step.
  • On Element (Matrix), recovery depends on a security key or passphrase. An unverified device can’t read your encrypted history, which protects your privacy but makes restoring it more complicated.
  • On Threema, a backup ID (Threema Safe) lets you restore contacts and settings, but not your full conversation history on a new phone.

Encrypting your conversations won’t protect anything if your backup is unencrypted. Before switching, check how each app handles restoration if your device is lost or replaced.

Two friends checking a secure alternative messaging app on a smartphone outdoors, protecting their personal data

Messaging app interoperability: what the DMA changes in Europe

One argument is consistently raised against WhatsApp alternatives: your contacts aren’t there. The European Union’s Digital Markets Act (DMA) aims to ease this problem. It requires major messaging platforms to make their services interoperable with third-party apps.

In practice, this means that a Signal or Element user could eventually receive messages sent from WhatsApp without the sender having to switch apps. The exact scope and timeline vary by service. Interoperability reduces the social pressure that discourages people from switching to messaging apps that better respect their privacy.

This change doesn’t eliminate the privacy differences between apps. An interoperable message passes through the servers of both platforms, raising questions about how much end-to-end encryption is maintained. Keeping an eye on the DMA’s practical implementation is the best approach before relying on this promise.

Choosing an open-source messaging app means weighing ease of adoption against technical control and actual privacy. Signal suits most family and personal use. Element is for organizations prepared to manage their own hosting. Threema removes the link to your phone number, but everyone in your circle has to pay for it. The best approach is to try one for two weeks with a small group before making a decision.

Which Open-Source WhatsApp Alternatives Best Protect Your Privacy?